Review Policy

Review Policy


Reviews are serious business. If done right, they could lead hundreds of people in the direction of a perfect game or keep people away from a stinker. Some people use reviews as the sole basis whether they get the game or not. However, others simply use it to see how it fairs with others, and then go out and get it for themselves. Here at Redhead Reviews, we are going for the later. We simply want to help you in making the decision for yourself. So, it’s been decided that our review system will be based out of 1-10 scale. There are 5 different categories in which leads to the final score. The categories are all between 1-10. The final scores for those categories are added up then divided by 5 to get the average, which is the final score.

The categories are:
Story – This can include the plot of the game, characters, plot twists, and a variety of similar things. Depending on the game, this category might change, such as in a sport game, to something that fits with the game. A game that would score highly in this category would be Catherine, which did something unique with its story.

Graphics – This category includes the the overall opinion of the graphics in the game, as well as textures, customization of characters/game world, and technical glitches such as texture pop-up. Also a sequel of a game that greatly improves the graphics since the first will also be discussed in this category. A game that would score highly in this category would be Uncharted 3.


Gameplay – The gameplay category includes the combat system, controls, level design, online play, and more. A game that would score highly in this category would be Grand Theft Auto IV, which offers a variety of mission and gameplay mechanics.

Sound – The sound category includes all sound effects in the game, such as the sounds coming from the guns or cars in a game, to the voice acting. This also includes any music in the game, and if the music fits well with what is happening on screen. A game that would score highly in this would be Red Dead Redemption, which offers excellent voice acting and authentic animal sounds from all the animals in the game.

Lasting appeal – This applies to the campaign length, collectibles, online reward system in multiplayer, difficulties, and more. A game that would score highly in this category would be Halo: Reach, which has a excellent online rewards system and challenging difficulties.

Take note that we will not release a review for a game if a proper playthrough has not been done.


The final score puts them in one of the following ratings. Depending on where it lies on the scale, the reviewer will decide where it fits best.


9.5/10.0 – Masterpiece
This is a game that will change the world. It far exceeds everyone’s expectations.
9 /9.5 – Epic
This is one of the best games out there. It may have a few flaws, but they are nothing compared to the pure awesomeness this game is.
8/8.5 – Great
This game is definitely worth your time. It may not be the best ever, but still enjoyable.
7/7.5 – Pretty cool
This game has issues, but it’s still fun nonetheless.
6/6.5 – Just okay
This game could have been great, but it’s has some issues that just can’t be ignored.
5/5.5 – Mediocre
A game that, if it sounds good, go ahead and give it a shot. However, it has about as many good things about it as it does bad.
4/4.5 – Bad
What were the developers thinking when they made this piece of crap?
3/3.5 – God Awful
Ever feel like pulling out your hair? This game will make you rip it all out, then glue it over your eyes because this game is just a downright mess.
2/2.5 – Painful
Don’t even think about picking up that controller.
1/1.5 – Just don’t
I’m warning you. Don’t do it, man.
0/0.5 – DON’T EVER PLAY THIS GAME.
You are either a god, or the biggest idiot in the world.


Remember that these reviews and our scoring system are designed just to help you make your decision on what you would like. Just because we say it’s a bad game doesn’t mean it will be the same for the guy down the street. Good reviews that we give might not be what others think at all. It’s just our opinion. You decide for yourself if a game is good or not.